A United Nations inquiry into attacks by Israeli forces on UN property during the Gaza conflict four months ago has heavily criticized Israel's army.
It found Israel to blame in six out of nine incidents when death
or injury were caused to people sheltering at UN property and UN
buildings were damaged.
In one case, Palestinian militants were found to have fired at a UN warehouse.
The Israeli Defence Minister, Ehud Barak, rejected the report, saying it was biased.
"We have the most moral army in the world," he said.
"IDF [Israeli Defense Force] commanders and soldiers made every effort to avoid hurting uninvolved civilians."
He accused Hamas of hiding its fighters among civilians and in the vicinity of UN installations.
The UN report says the Israeli military took "inadequate"
precautions to protect UN premises and civilians inside and recommends
further investigation into possible war crimes.
One of the incidents highlighted in the document is the firing of
artillery shells near a UN-run school in Jabalia where Palestinians
were sheltering on 6 January.
The panel says more than 40 people died outside the school - Israel
says only 12 were killed, and seven of them were "terror operatives".
The board of inquiry also criticises Israel's use of white
phosphorus shells which the UN says caused the incineration of the UN's
main food warehouse in Gaza.
Reparations sought
The BBC's Laura Trevelyan at the UN says it is a hard-hitting report
which includes heavy criticism of the Israeli military's actions and
subsequent explanations and justifications.
The UN board's first recommendation seeks "formal acknowledgment" by
Israel that its initial public statement that Palestinians had fired
from the school grounds and from within the UN field office compound
"were untrue and are regretted".
A later Israeli inquiry said militants had fired from a site about 80m away from the school.
Israel also contends that Hamas militants had positioned themselves near the UN relief agency headquarters.
Another recommendation says the UN should take appropriate action to
seek reparation for all deaths and injuries involving its personnel and
property.
The report says Israel's actions were in breach of the agreement
that UN premises and those sheltering within them should be immune from
attack, something which cannot be set aside for military action.
The board says investigating the deaths outside the UN school is outside its remit.
It recommends that this and allegations of war crimes committed in
Gaza and southern Israel by Palestinian militants and Israel should be
investigated by another inquiry.
UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has stressed this report is not a legal document.
|